Submission 472
How Tall Is a Boy Who Isn’T Short? Evidence from a Picture Selection Task
SymposiumTalk-01
Presented by: Elena Albu
Relative adjectives yield distinct interpretations under negation depending on their polarity (Horn, 1989; Colston, 1999; Ruytenbeek et al., 2017; Tessler & Franke, 2019; Gotzner & Mazzarella, 2021; Gotzner & Kiziltan, 2022). Negating positive adjectives (i.e., not tall), typically results in strengthened to the antonym interpretations (i.e., rather short), whereas negating negative adjectives (i.e., not short) gives rise to middling interpretations (i.e., neither tall nor short). In a series of studies, we investigate whether the observed polarity asymmetry generalizes across a broader range of adjective pairs and different linguistic structures. In Study 1, we assessed the polarity of 54 pairs of adjectives in a picture-selection task, where affirmative and negative sentences (i.e., John is (not) tall / short) were presented together with three different pictures, depicting a tall boy, a short boy and a boy that is neither tall nor short, respectively. The results revealed that, for affirmative sentences, participants chose the pictures matching the adjective for most adjectives. For negative sentences, they predominantly chose the picture depicting the opposite state, regardless of adjective polarity. This pattern suggests that the adjectives were largely assessed as positive. However, it is possible that participants relied on task-specific strategies rather than focusing on the actual interpretation of the adjectives. To address this, we are currently running a follow-up study with instructions designed to directly probe the interpretations of the negated relative adjectives and to assess more accurately their polarity.