15:40 - 17:20
Room: Meeting Room 2.1
Chair/s:
Ringailė Kuokštytė
Ringailė Kuokštytė - NATO Membership and Defense Spending: A Causal Analysis
Jeanne Pinay - Colonial Wars and Modern Nationalism: Evidence from Fascist Italy's Campaigns in East Africa
Daniil Chernov - In Search of the True Self: A Behavioral Allocation Game for Measuring Empowerment
Nolan McCarty - The Political Corporation
Amy Basu - Bread or Circuses? The Conundrum of Non-Contingent Clientelism and the Informal Economy
Submission 424
Bread or Circuses? The Conundrum of Non-Contingent Clientelism and the Informal Economy
Panel.8-S-3
Presented by: Amy Basu
Amy Basu
Yale University
This paper investigates a central puzzle in the study of money in politics: why do candidates spend heavily on non-contingent, pre-election handouts when the secret ballot precludes direct vote monitoring? Conventional theories of campaign finance and clientelism focus on programmatic spending in the form of pork-barrel politics or quid-pro-quo exchange. We propose an alternative mechanism: non-contingent handouts function as a signal of electoral viability, funded by clientelistic state capture, dependent on the informal economic sector.

In our formal model, the electorate is bifurcated: a formal sector responsive to programmatic policy ("bread") and an informal sector lacking legal entitlements. These informal voters are strategic, seeking to support the winning candidate to gain future discretionary benefits. Candidates trade policy concessions for elite funding. which is then strategically deployed. Candidates expend captured funds to stage "circuses"—costly, non-contingent handouts that incentivize high-visibility public participation (e.g., large rallies). We demonstrate this strategy is optimal in polities with high economic inequality and a large informal sector, as these conditions create a voter bloc unresponsive to traditional programmatic appeals.