16:50 - 18:30
PS10
Room:
Room: South Room 225
Panel Session 10
Sebastian Ramirez-Ruiz - Cheating in Online Assessments of Political Knowledge: Evidence from Digital Trace Data
Jakob Kemper - Piloting Experimental Tests of Macro-Micro-Level Effects in an Artificial Online State: How Income Inequalities Affect Political Solidarities
Jakob Kemper - The behavioural consequences of political solidarities: Validating the solidarity game on a representative online sample with real-time interaction in oTree
Hannah Bucher - Analyzing voting behavior with different survey samples: Results from a large-scale comparison of a nonprobability and a probability survey.
Piloting Experimental Tests of Macro-Micro-Level Effects in an Artificial Online State: How Income Inequalities Affect Political Solidarities
PS10-2
Presented by: Jakob Kemper
Achim GoerresJan Karem HöhneJakob Kemper
University of Duisburg-Essen
What if we could artificially manipulate the level of income inequality in a society and causally estimate its effects on political solidarities? This paper presents exploratory evidence from a pilot study of Novaland, an online state in which volunteers act and interact on a text-based platform. Thereby, the online behaviour of participants affects their actual financial pay-out. This novel research design builds on text adventures in pedagogy and gaming, on social psychological role-taking by experimental design, and on behavioural and survey instruments. The main causal effects analysed are whether absolute levels of and relative changes in income inequality affect political solidarities, that is, the individual willingness to support public redistribution in favour of other social groups. Theoretically, the paper concentrates on individual-level mechanisms from the Meltzer-Richards-Model and the Deservingness Literature.
The paper systematically presents the technical realisation of the pilot platform. In addition, it reviews measures of internal validity (do participants behave predictably and consistently within the experiment?). Finally, the paper puts forward assessments of external validity (do causal effects in the online world reflect actual causal effects outside?).
If the pilot study demonstrated promising signs of valid measurements, it would open up a completely new avenue for research on the link between macro-level characteristics of societies and states, such as income inequality, and micro-level social, economic and political behaviour, such as political solidarities.