13:10 - 14:50
P3
Room:
Room: Meeting Room 2.3
Panel Session 3
Jean Lacroix - The Origins of Elite Persistence: Evidence from Political Purges in post-World War II France
Lucas M. Novaes - The Autocracy Bandwagon: Political Survival and Democratic Backsliding
Adrian del Rio - Beyond Elite Dissent. New Dimensions and Data for the Study of Elite Defections in Electoral Autocracies
Victoria Paniagua, Joan Ricart-Huguet - Political Elites in Argentina: Representation in the Executive and the Legislature as Substitutes
The Origins of Elite Persistence: Evidence from Political Purges in post-World War II France
P3-1
Presented by: Jean Lacroix
Jean Lacroix 1, Toke Aidt 2, Pierre-Guillaume Méon 3
1 Université Paris-Saclay
2 Cambridge
3 ULB
This paper studies a new mechanism that allows political elites from a non-democratic regime to survive a democratic transition: connections. We document this mechanism in the transition from the Vichy regime back to democracy in post-World War II France. The politicians who had supported the Vichy regime were purged in a two-stage process whereby local courts, Comites departementaux de liberation (CDLs) and a national court, the Jury d'Honneur, sequentially decided whether to uphold the ban on participation in politics for each defendant. First, we show that the Jury was more likely than the CDLs to clear defendants who were Law graduates, a powerful group in French politics at the time. The difference in clearance rates between Law graduates and other defendants was 10 percentage points higher in front of the Jury than in front of the CDLs. This Law graduate advantage was consequential and created elite persistence, as it mainly appeared when defendants intended on continuing their political careers.
Second, a systematic analysis of the still-classified 17,589 documents contained in the Jury dossiers of the defendants is consistent with the hypothesis that the connections of Law graduates to the Jury was a major driver of their ability to avoid the purge. We consider and rule out alternative mechanisms.